Can an Employer Dismiss an Employee for Medical Incapacity in Malaysia?

Can an employer in Malaysia dismiss an employee on medical grounds even if a doctor says they’re fit to work? An Industrial Court award shows why the answer depends on what the employee can actually do. I explain how medical assessments, workplace adjustments and alternative duties can shape the decision, and why running out of sick leave doesn’t settle it.

An employee returns to work after a stroke. His doctor says he is fit to work. A few months later, his employer ends his employment on medical grounds.

Can the employer do that?

In Leong Teck Ming v Kashima (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd (Award No. 1846 of 2026), the Industrial Court upheld the termination. But the most useful part of the decision is what happened between the doctor’s note and the termination letter.

What Happened in Leong Teck Ming v Kashima?

Leong had worked for the company since 2006 and was its Quality Control (QC) Manager. After he suffered a stroke in November 2023, the company granted him a combination of paid sick leave, annual leave and unpaid leave. He returned in June 2024 with a hospital memo saying he was fit to work, while noting residual weakness in his left hand. The memo did not identify which duties he could carry out.

That mattered because his QC role involved taking precise measurements of products. The rehabilitation assessment noted that his grip could make it difficult to hold and position items for measurement. It recommended lighter duties and workplace adjustments.

The company temporarily assigned him to sales and marketing. That kept him working, but the role involved customer visits. The court heard that company executives personally drove him to those visits because of concerns about whether he could drive safely.

A later occupational health report went further than the hospital memo. It found him fit to work as QC Manager subject to recommended adjustments, including a phased return and monitoring for fatigue. The company took the position that it could not put the recommended arrangements in place within its operational limits. It treated the employment contract as frustrated, and his employment ended on 14 October 2024.

Why Did the Industrial Court Uphold the Termination?

The court did not find that the employee was incapable of doing any work. It found that his continuing limitations prevented him from adequately performing the core duties of the job he was employed to do. It accepted that the temporary sales assignment was not a viable long-term solution and that the company could not accommodate the recommended changes within its workplace constraints.

The court also considered what the employer had done before ending the employment: it kept Leong employed for more than 11 months after the stroke, allowed him to return, tried an alternative assignment and obtained a further occupational health assessment. That was 11 months in employment after the stroke.

The court found that the contract had been frustrated by prolonged incapacity and concluded that the termination was with just cause and excuse. It dismissed the claim.

What Does “Frustration” Mean in an Employment Contract?

Frustration is not a synonym for inconvenience. Section 57(2) of the Contracts Act 1950 addresses what happens when contractual performance becomes impossible or unlawful after the contract was made.

In the employment context, a serious and prolonged incapacity may exceptionally frustrate a contract if the employee cannot perform the work they were engaged to do in the foreseeable future. It is not enough to put the word “frustrated” in a letter and assume the legal test has been met.

I find it helpful to separate three questions: Has the employee exhausted paid sick leave? What work can the employee actually do? Can the employment reasonably continue? They are not the same question.

Section 60F of the Employment Act 1955 deals with sick leave entitlement. It does not make the last day of paid sick leave an automatic termination date. Nor is medical incapacity, in itself, a misconduct.

What Should Employers Check Before Terminating on Medical Grounds?

The first thing an employer should probably look into would be the employee’s actual job scope, alongside the latest medical assessment.

A diagnosis tells you what happened to the employee. It does not, by itself, tell you what they can safely do at work.

  1. Ask for an assessment that addresses the job scope. Give the medical professional an accurate description of the essential duties. Ask about functional limits, safety, expected recovery and when to reassess.
  2. Speak to the employee before deciding. Explain the concerns, invite their response and discuss whether a staged return or temporary adjustment would work. A person may be able to do more, or less, than the first memo suggests.
  3. Test the practical alternatives. Consider whether adjustments, light duties or a suitable existing vacancy would let the person continue working safely. If an option is not workable, record why. The court accepted the company’s limitations on the facts of Leong; that is not a blanket exemption from considering adjustments.
  4. Check the procedure and keep a written record. Review the contract, handbook and any collective agreement for a medical assessment or medical board-out process. Record the medical evidence, discussions and alternatives considered before making a decision. Assess applicable notice and payment obligations separately.

The question is not simply whether the employee has fully recovered. It is whether they can perform the essential duties safely, with workable adjustments, and what the evidence says about their prospects of returning to those duties.

What If You Are the Employee?

Ask your doctor to explain which duties you can perform and what changes would help. Put any proposed adjustments in writing and keep copies of your medical assessments, return-to-work communications and termination letter.

If you believe you were dismissed without just cause or excuse, seek advice promptly. A representation for reinstatement under section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967 is generally due within 60 days of dismissal.

Continue Learning About Malaysian Employment Law

For practicle articles on employment rights, dismissal and Industrial Court claims, explore Employment Law Malaysia: The Complete Guide for Employees and Employers (2026)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *