Can an Employer Terminate an Employee by Giving Notice Alone in Malaysia?

Can an employer dismiss an employee simply by giving contractual notice? Two Malaysian Industrial Court awards involving a father and son show why notice alone is insufficient. This article examines retirement, absenteeism, outside business activities and social media evidence, explaining why employers must establish a genuine reason for dismissal rather than introduce justifications after the decision has already been made.

One month’s notice. Two dismissals. RM378,200 in Industrial Court awards.

An employment contract may say that either party can end the relationship by giving notice or paying salary in lieu. It is easy to read that as a straightforward exit clause.

For employers, however, there is another question: what is the reason for dismissal?

Two related awards involving a father and son show why that question matters. In Ishak bin Amin v IM Global Property Consultants Sdn Bhd (Award No. 1905 of 2026) and Muhammad Noor Izami bin Ishak v IM Global Property Consultants Sdn Bhd (Award No. 1906 of 2026), the Industrial Court found both dismissals unfair.

The company gave contractual notice. What it could not establish was a genuine, sufficiently supported justification for the dismissals.

What Happened in the Two Cases?

Ishak and his son, Muhammad Noor Izami, joined the company’s Melaka branch in January 2016 as General Manager and Manager respectively.

On 1 November 2023, both received termination notices ending their employment on 30 November 2023. The notices were substantially identical, apart from the clause numbers referring to their respective notice provisions. Neither specified a substantive reason for dismissal.

The claims were heard together, but the Court issued separate awards on 4 November 2026.

The employer’s explanations differed. In Ishak’s case, it ultimately relied on retirement. In Izami’s case, it relied on absenteeism and involvement in outside business activities.

Does Contractual Notice Make a Dismissal Fair?

Not on its own.

Notice and justification are separate issues. Complying with the notice period does not remove an employee’s protection against dismissal without just cause or excuse under section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967.

Termination by notice without a substantive justification is commonly called termination simpliciter.

In practical terms, the notice clause tells the employee when the employment ends. The employer still needs to explain why.

The Father’s Case: Was It Really Retirement?

Ishak’s contract contained a retirement clause specifying age 55. The company continued employing him beyond that age, without varying his employment terms. He was approximately 60 years and four months old when dismissed.

The company argued that it had exercised discretion to extend his service and was entitled to end it after he passed retirement age.

However, the termination notice did not mention retirement. More importantly, the Court found no convincing evidence that retirement was the actual reason operating in the company’s mind when it decided to dismiss him.

The company had also raised absenteeism, but ultimately confirmed that it relied on retirement, not absenteeism or misconduct. The Court therefore did not decide whether absenteeism justified Ishak’s dismissal.

For employees covered by the Minimum Retirement Age Act 2012, the statutory minimum is generally 60, and section 7 replaces a lower contractual retirement age with the statutory minimum. Employers should not assume that an old compulsory-retirement clause at 55 remains enforceable.

The award does not mean employees can never be retired at 60. It shows why the applicable retirement terms, continued employment and genuine reason for termination need to be established.

The Son’s Case: Did Facebook Prove His Absenteeism?

The company alleged that Izami missed meetings and travelled for his personal YouTube-related activities.

The evidence did not support those allegations in the way the company suggested.

WhatsApp messages showed that explanations for missed meetings had been communicated and acknowledged. A separate allegation about a missed course lacked a specific date and was not put to him during cross-examination.

There was also a Facebook post appearing to place him in Switzerland on 18 November 2023. Izami said he was in Malaysia and that the post was a throwback.

The Court accepted that explanation. A posting date did not necessarily establish when the photograph was taken or where he was on that day.

This does not make social-media evidence worthless. It means its timing and context should be checked against attendance records, communications and the employee’s explanation.

What About His Outside Business Activities?

Izami’s contract restricted outside business or employment without prior written consent. He admitted not obtaining consent for his personal YouTube activities.

That sounds significant, until the employer’s own conduct enters the picture.

The company had previously showcased his YouTube channel during a headquarters course as an example of online marketing. The Court considered its knowledge, encouragement and lack of action inconsistent with its later explanation for dismissal. It found condonation and was not persuaded that the alleged breach genuinely motivated the dismissal.

The lesson is not that employees may freely ignore outside-work restrictions. Nor does every period of silence necessarily amount to approval.

Employers should address known concerns promptly and consistently, rather than praise an activity and later rely on it as a reason for dismissal without explaining the change.

Can an Employer Introduce Reasons After Dismissal?

Both awards applied the Federal Court’s decision in Maritime Intelligence Sdn Bhd v Tan Ah Gek [2022] 1 MLRA 56.

The Court examines the reasons actually operating in the employer’s mind when dismissal was decided. Employers cannot retrospectively justify that decision using fresh reasons chosen afterwards.

There is a distinction worth preserving: omitting a reason from the termination letter does not automatically prevent the employer from proving it. The employer must still establish that it genuinely formed the basis of dismissal.

How Much Did the Court Award?

EmployeeBack wagesCompensation in lieu of reinstatementTotal
IshakRM200,000None awardedRM200,000
IzamiRM132,000RM46,200RM178,200
CombinedRM332,000RM46,200RM378,200

Both received 20 months’ back wages. Izami additionally received seven months’ salary as compensation in lieu of reinstatement. Ishak did not receive that component because the Court applied retirement-related authorities when considering the remedy.

These were separate awards, subject to applicable statutory deductions. Both required payment within 30 days, with 8% annual interest accruing after that period until settlement.

Practical Lessons for Employers and Employees

Before issuing a termination letter, employers should identify the genuine reason, check the supporting evidence and give the employee an appropriate opportunity to respond. The letter should accurately reflect the decision already made.

Employees should preserve their contracts, termination notices, leave approvals and relevant messages. In these cases, the surrounding communications mattered far more than a bare reference to a notice clause.

Anyone considering an unfair dismissal claim should seek advice promptly. Section 20 representations are generally subject to a 60-day deadline.

Final Thoughts

A notice clause is useful. It is not a substitute for a defensible reason.

These two awards are a reminder to investigate first, decide on the evidence and then write the letter. Doing those steps in reverse can be an expensive exercise.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *